How Twitter impacts media and journalism: Five Fundamental Factors

By

One of the most interesting issues regarding Twitter is its impact on the media and journalism. The Insight Exchange is running a lunch event Twitter’s Impact on Media & Journalism in Sydney on 23 June which promises to be extremely interesting, with insights from among others Mark Pesce, Renai Lemay, Paul Colgan and Corrie McLeod (click on the names to see pre-event interviews of the speakers by Beth Etling) as well as in-depth discussion by all participants.

Below are some of my thoughts on the topic. As an introduction, in the ABC TV segment below Mark Scott, Managing Director of ABC and myself are interviewed about the role of Twitter in media. Mark emphasizes that people want a trusted source for their news, whereas I point to the value of Twitter in breaking news. At the time I wrote more about these different viewpoints on Twitter and media, noting that Scott’s stance “just takes us back to the traditional view that news is only news once a journalist has reported it.”

I see Five Fundamental Factors on how Twitter impacts media and journalism:

1. Twitter’s role in breaking news

In my book Living Networks, released in 2002, I wrote:

The brilliant visionary Marshall McLuhan accurately described the media as an extension of our senses. Your eyes can see what’s happening in your immediate vicinity, your ears can hear what people are saying in the same room as you, but with television and radio as an adjunct to your senses, you can see and hear anywhere around the world. All of the cameras and microphones of the world’s media are an extension of your eyes and ears, and journalists are your personal emissaries to report on their findings and impressions.

Now connectivity is extending your senses to all the connected people on their planet. Media is becoming a participatory sport. You can tap into what any of a vast army of people are seeing and thinking, or contribute yourself to the global flow. This certainly doesn’t mean the end of mass media. Most people will always choose to access a common frame on the world, that gives views of politics, society, and entertainment that provide a basis for interaction and discussion. However the new world of media is at the heart of how the networks are coming to life.

[From Chapter 1 of Living Networks]

This is exactly what is happening today. Twitter is extending our collective senses to tens of millions of people around the world who can all report on whatever they are seeing, making that available to anyone on the planet.

This has been evident in many news events around the world, including the Mumbai terrorist attacks, the plane landing in the Hudson, and most recently the unrest following the Iranian elections. There is no question that we have far richer and more timely information on major and minor events around the world as they happen.

2. The accuracy and verification of news on Twitter

I don’t think anyone thinks that everything on Twitter is the gospel truth. Often information is inaccurate, through misinterpretation or sometimes deliberately. However the vast majority of people are able to make a judgment on the likely accuracy of news – be it on CNN or Twitter – and to take it in the context of other news sources.

First hand reports may need confirmation, but they provide early information which can later be corroborated or complemented by other sources. This is the role of professional journalists and established media, which have the resources, training, and expertise to check information and pull together a balanced view of the story. Twitter absolutely does not obviate the need for professional media – it complements it by providing first-hand reporting from a vast army of people on the ground, which is then filtered and integrated into mainstream reporting. This rigorous next phase of media creation and dissemination is necessary and desirable.

There will be some people who are happy to wait until the mainstream media process the news and release it on the regularly scheduled TV news program or in the newspaper. However these days most people prefer their news fresh.

3. The pressure for faster news and media

There is no question that the quickening pace of communication over the last years, including the rise of Twitter, has heightened our expectation of the timeliness of news. Moreover, I believe that humans’ appetite for news and information is effectively insatiable, so we are never going to get to the point at which news is sufficiently fast and deep.

Since bloggers started to compete with mainstream media for breaking news, the pressure has ramped up on being the first to post. Whoever gets in first with news usually gets the bulk of attention and traffic. With Twitter added to the fray, the competition is even more intense.

The inevitable result, bemoaned by many traditional journalists, is that being correct is subjugated to being first. Attitudes are increasingly that it’s better to be first out and have to correct than to delay too long.

4. Editorial policies and reputation for accuracy

The balance between timeliness and accuracy is ultimately an editorial decision. To what degree are you willing to jeopardize your reputation for accuracy to be first out with the news? Over time different media (mainstream and long-tail) will make and implement their choices, establishing an effective hierarchy of reputation for news accuracy. As such, news that comes from the most trusted sources will be considered to be correct and not need further verification. Other news sources will more often be first out with the news, but the audience will understand that this is not 100% credible. We will all make our choices as to which array of faster or more accurate news sources we will use.

5. The symbiosis of mainstream media and Twitter

I have written numerous times about the symbiosis of mainstream media and social media– each feeds on the other. I also used this metaphor as a central element of my Future of Media Strategic Framework below.

Future_of_Media_Strategic_Framework.jpg

This is and should be exactly the relationship between mainstream media and Twitter. Absolutely, Twitter largely feeds off established media channels. In fact it is rapidly becoming one of the most important ways for people to assess which mainstream media stories they choose to read. Twitterers select what’s most interesting, and then often comment on it, creating real-time conversations out of a static media piece.

However mainstream media is feeding off Twitter too. As Twitter grows its user base it is becoming not just a source of breaking news, but also a deep and broad indicator of sentiment and social change. News stories are not all about cataclysmic events, but also about how we are changing as a society. Journalists who do not look to Twitter as an early indicator or potential source of stories are missing a great opportunity to tap the zeitgeist.

Recommended reading on Twitter’s impact on media and journalism

There is much more to say about Twitter’s impact on media and journalism, so I’ll try to write more about this topic later. For now I’ll close with some recommended reading on what is an extremely important topic for society.

Robert Scoble: The day Twitter kicked CNN’s behind & @ev bought me a whisky

Robert Niles/ Online Journalism Review: So why aren’t you Twittering yet?

Jay Rosen: Help Me Explain Twitter to Eggheads(read the comments)

Mashable: The Journalist’s Guide to Twitter

Rory O’Connor/ Biz Stone: Twitter Journalism

Mathew Ingram: Yes, Twitter is a source of journalism

David Schlesinger: Twittering away standards or tweeting the future of journalism?

Jeff Jarvis: Product v. process journalism: The myth of perfection v. beta culture

  • Microblogs
    Microblogs are the fastest mass public media.
    If the spead of information travelling defines a society, a global revolution is taking place: global immediate mass communication is now a fact due to the microblogs.
    Pieter Jansegers
    http://webosophy.ning.com

  • Microblogs
    Microblogs are the fastest mass public media.
    If the spead of information travelling defines a society, a global revolution is taking place: global immediate mass communication is now a fact due to the microblogs.
    Pieter Jansegers
    http://webosophy.ning.com
    jasonlorRT: “First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.” Mahatma Gandhi #iranelection

  • Anonymous

    Previously tweed was practical because of its moisture resistance and reliability but soon was superseded because the production and expense could not keep

    up with the worlds growing demands and industry boom. gucci messenger bags

    So they converted to cheaper materials Lucky for us Coach knows that quality is better than quantity and tweed as well as their other Signature materials

    will always be a commodity. Have you ever noticed that tweed have outlived the years better than cheap materials. small coach purses

    This is what sets the Coach apart from the rest.

    Whatever your taste: small, large, medium, tweed, leather, fancy, vintage, classic, reliable, durable, dependable, Coach Soho has what you want. gucci shoulder bag

    They may cost a little more but truthfully you get what you pay for. So it is a relief to know that it will last; not just as in it will not fall apart, but

    last as in; Coach products will always be in. Whatever the rage happens to be, you can sleep easy knowing that the Soho line and hobo design will dominate

    the competition.

    The Soho reminds me of Breakfast at Tiffany’s. Audrey Hepburn is the picture of vintage style.online gucci

    outlet
    Like Coach Soho, it is the Crème de la Crème of early styles that became illustrious not just by flair but by the beauty and spunk they bring to any woman.

    So a Soho won’t make you look like Audrey Hepburn but it will make you feel like one.gucci purses

    Guest post by Milla Mahno

  •  

    I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post thanks.Famously line 
    for grace and Kristin Christine series in this one season evolved slim decorative clasp and beautiful geometrical modelling

  • Anonymous

    Actually utilized the louis vuitton outlet covering a not  ramos nakedness, glittering valencia metal waist albelda was in for just about  any charity the donation and supra shoes  nude, will hang inside the neck, shoes gucci outlet a football blocking delicate  areas. even although innovation consciousness is not strong, but ramos but is  very much more louis vuitton bags outlet , with purchase gucci bags prolonged supra  sneakers straight as his predecessor occlusions, has not inferior.An  excellent standard performance in the season, allow gucci purses sale usage brightness all  praise Barcelona adjectives.

  • Christian Louboutin sales
  • Cheappradabags
  • Cheappradabags
  • Cheappradabags
  • supra shoes
  • supra shoes

    [url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Womens-Supra-TK-Society-15/]Womens Supra TK Society[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-TK-Society-9/]Supra TK Society[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Vaider-12/]Supra Vaider[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Skytop-1/]Supra Skytop[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Skytop-I-17/]Supra Skytop I[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Skytop-II-2/]Supra Skytop II[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Skytop-III-3/]Supra Skytop III [/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Skytop-NS-4/]Supra Skytop NS [/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Strapped-NS-6/]Supra Strapped NS [/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Cruizer-7/]Supra Cruizer [/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Cuban-8/]Supra Cuban[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Suprano-High-10/]Supra Suprano High[/url][url=http://www.womenssuprashoes.com/Supra-Thunder-Hightop-11/]Supra Thunder Hightop[/url]

  • nike air max outlet

    url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com]nike air max outlet[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com]cheap nike air max[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com]air max shoes[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-2012-4/]NIKE AIR MAX 2012[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-2011-3/]NIKE AIR MAX 2011[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-2010-18/]NIKE AIR MAX 2010[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-2009-19/]NIKE AIR MAX 2009[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-88-6/]NIKE AIR MAX 88[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-90-8/]NIKE AIR MAX 90[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-91-9/]NIKE AIR MAX 91[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-92-10/]NIKE AIR MAX 92[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-93-11/]NIKE AIR MAX 93[/url]
    [url=http://www.nike-air-max-outlet.com/Nike-Air-Max-95-12/]NIKE AIR MAX 95[/url]

  • Yuehuosudou Sale

    You could feel the top quality with hands promptly while you touch a louis vuitton uk. Pay attention that each LV bag is well-produced and meant to last for a lengthy time. louis vuitton uk are ideal for daily usage. With the beautifully crafted exterior and with loads of interior space for all the essentials, it will adorn any outfit with city elegance. Different style bags from beats by dre are always eloquent statement outside a woman’s attitude towards life and career. Thus, women’s bag, must exchange the use of occasions, so they are not the same as showing different spatial and temporal rhythm of beauty. Today, following half a century, mentor leather-bases dr dre beats continues to be the delicate craft of leather-based master is accountable for, This pair of rhodium-plated ralph lauren uk Earrings form elegant semi-circles with a dangling element embellished in clear crystal pave. Wear them with your everyday outfit to add a touch of eye-catching elegance. coach outlet sells products which are excellent in quality and reasonable in price. All customers can easily pick up their favorite Coach briefcase, wallets, shoes, hats, scarf, jewelry and sunglasses. coach outlet online Store guarantee that all the coach handbags offered are own high quality. In addition , all of them are sold at an unexpected low price.If you want to purchase, just visit their website. If you want to buy quality Coach products at lower prices, visiting coach outlet online can be your best decision.