The dilemma for professionals: How do you respond to anonymous leaks and slander?


Today’s Australian Financial Review has an interesting article titled “Watch out for the spook in the navy blue suit” which looks at how professionals can respond to anonymous slander, quoting me and a few others.

It looks at FirmSpy, which is a site that provides gossip about Australian professional firms, notably law firms and the local arms of the Big 4 accounting firms. FirmSpy provides insights into internal issues such as bullying, sexual harassment, and staff satisfaction and turnover, resulting in Australian Financial Review calling it “Australia’s own Wikileaks for lawyers and accountants”.

For those accused of wrongdoing, there are limited possibilities for response. The article says:

Social media strategist Ross Dawson says it is inevitable that more sites such as Firm Spy will spring up and organisations need to decide how they will deal with cristicim that can be from anonymous sources, or through social media such as Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn groups.

“This is is one of the challenges of the online world, and there are a limited range of responses to it,” says Dawson, chairman of Advanced Human Technologies.

The possible responses are:
1. To contact the site and ask it to take down offending material.
This is pretty unlikely to be useful, though if you can convince the publisher it is incorrect they might do something. Firm Spy now offers a right of response to firms before publication, and says it does not publish information that turns out to be incorrect.

2. To threaten legal action for defamation.
In the case of anonymous sites this can only be delivered through anonymized remailers, and legal action can only be taken if there is someone who can be identified, which is very difficult. However a FirmSpy representative says they expect to be uncovered, at which point legal proceedings can be launched. However, as in point 4 below, this will simply highlight the issue to the public.

3. To conduct internal witch-hunts to find who has leaked material.
This implies the information is correct, so this is a stop-gap measure at best.

4. To publicly respond to the accusations.
This a very dangerous strategy as it most often brings far more attention to the slurs than they would have received otherwise. However if you do you should do that on a similar social platform to where they originally appeared. The journalist used the example I gave of the CEO of Carnival Cruises’ YouTube videos responding to videos taken by passengers.

The article goes on:

“Being engaged in social media gives you a right of response… competing by press release is singularly ineffective,” says Dawson.

Overreacting could make an ugly situation even worse, he warns, pointing to Nestle’s action to remove a Greenpeace protest video, which spoofed a Kit Kat ad in a campaign against the use of palm oil.

Some Australian law firms have blocked FirmSpy on work computers, however they soon realized it was pointless as traffic to the site jumped 50% after the bans, and they allowed access again.

Dawson says the emergence of whistleblowing sites can have a positive impact – and not just for those who need to get something off their chests.

“I think transparency of institutions is a good thing. It is also an inevitable trend,” he says.

The article goes on to look at social media monitoring and reinforcing the messages of positive response, which I cover in our social media strategy framework. The piece ends with a nice quote from a Deloitte executive who says:

“The day you can micro control your brand image is gone forever.”

Absolutely. We need to learn to live with transparency and the fact that sometimes things said about us will be unfair. In the reputation economy the genuinely positive will almost always outweigh the falsely negative. As long as we know how to engage and be seen.

  • Amarias

    Clear as water, and very useful to all people interested in building-up a better world (being simultaneously conscious about the most effective tools to achieve that enormous goal)

  • Yetta_alberta

    My friends got very disappointed about that. But we forgot that there’s another way which may solve the problem—Internet. We went to the on-line shop that selling christian lebouton sheepskin wood heels pumps black, and have an amazing discovery. There’re various of christian louboutin shoes on-line, although we know they are imitation. And everything went smoothly after all. And fortunately the goods we bought from the Internet are well made and pretty. So interesting experience it is! Every season, Christian Louboutin and his designers will design several beautiful and gorgeous shoes in different styles. But the red sole has never changed. And it seems that Christian Louboutin is challenging the height of the high heeled shoes every year. We all know that christian louboutin very priver patent leather peep toe high are famous for the height of heels. But it is said that christian louboutin alta even designed some high heels in 16cm this season. Is true or not ? We can know it only until the new productions of Christian Louboutin shoes appear on the market.

    The height of the heel of the four shoes are almost the same. As to the first ones, i love the wide opening in the front which is very popular this year. For the second ones, i love the parcel design which give me a feeling of super women, and it can also have the function of keep warm. For the third ones, i love the tip head which looks really sexy, i can image the situation when wearing it which will be gorgeous. For the fourth ones, i love the straps with the gold color which reveaThe leopard element seems in a high popularity this year, so Christian Louboutin also designed several styles of christian louboutin black lace pumps. And Christian Louboutin heels are famous for their red soles and high height of heels. So Christian Loubouti shoes are also called sky-high heels. And Christian Louboutin loves to use hidden platform to make the shoes more comfortable. Here is one pair of hidden platform Christian Louboutin leopard heels.

    There’re many other famous high heeled shoes brand. But christian louboutin aurora boreale is unique as to the red soles, but YSL copied this logo and adopt the red sole which is regarded as violate the patent, and the case is under processing. Actually it’s not so easily to protect this color patent, but i hope this thing can have a happy ending.Many super stars are interested in Christian Louboutin, including the gossip girl Blake Lively and Victoria Becham. How could it have the charming to make more than 3000 females own more than 500 hundred pairs of Christian Louboutin pumps in the world? It is a miracle. You will never know how it feels until you truly own a pair of christian louboutin altadama 140mm patent pumps in a royal savour.

    The second way is get the discount shoes onsale information from the fashion magazine, they will list the lastest price of the shoes and also some matching clothes. This can not only help you find the discount shoes on sale, but also give more useful advice to dress up yourself.

    Women are the group who love and enjoy shopping, i am one of them, and sometimes i am thinking about how can i choose the pretty clothing but save much money at the same time. Then i remind of the wholesale clothing for women.

    When i attend to the party, i try to pay much attention to every detail, but things goes opposite. Someone pushed me when i was trying to get a cup of wine from the sever and all the wine poured to me, what a terrible thing! And what’s worse, the brooch is broken because of that and the gown dresses turned into a bit of large which make me looks so funny. i want to find a hole to put myself in at that time.

  • Yejianqiang3001
  • Eshoppingcoach
  • Tessa Ye