Personal reputation systems are about to take off… but the next start-up won’t last


Michael Arrington of Techcrunch writes that this week a start-up will launch that is “effectively Yelp for people,” and promises detailed coverage in the next few days.

This is of great interest, not least because our own start-up Repyoot will be launching in public beta in the next couple of weeks, starting as an influence ratings engine within a limited domain, and intending to evolve into a broad-based reputation engine for people.

The thrust of Arrington’s article is that if we are all open to anonymous feedback…

It’s time for a centralized, well organized place for anonymous mass defamation on the Internet. Scary? Yes. But it’s coming nonetheless.

…we will have to change how we judge reputation.

We’re going to be forced to adjust as a society. I firmly believe that we will simply become much more accepting of indiscretions over time. Employers just won’t care that ridiculous drunk college pictures pop up about you when they do a HR background search on you.

In 2007 I expressed similar sentiments in Watch out! The intimate details of your life will be visible forever more…, saying

It is inevitable that organizations will become more forgiving about what they discover their candidates and employees getting up to. They never knew in the past, so finding out what goes on outside of business shouldn’t change things. Otherwise the employee pool diminishes too much. … So today, as we become highly visible in a range of different situations, including in the wilder situations we end up in, as well as of course expressing our opinions, open-mindedness becomes more relevant, and people can be seen more as they are rather than as the corporate persona they often assume.

However another critical issue is the quality of the reputation systems. One model is to enable unlimited anonymous feedback and rating, which it sounds like this start-up is going to adopt. While this approach may get traction for a while, it simply won’t last.

The context is that reliable reputation measures would transform the global economy. The reduction in transaction costs that we’ve seen through the rise of the Internet would pale in comparison to what would result from having a good sense of a person’s or company’s context-specific reputation before dealing with them. Far more sophisticated reputation measures will be required for this to be valuable. A forum for gripes would be useless.

I’ll comment more when I see the actual launch, but from what little Arrington has said about the forthcoming service, I doubt it will be an important enabler of the reputation economy, or successful in the long-run, though it could well get a lot of hype and interest for a while.

  • OSG

    And you’re basing your comments on this concept on Arrington’s post?
    His post had little substance and even less thought.
    Could not a meaningful reputation site have value?
    Linked-In’s referrals are basically useless……nothing more than mutual admiration circles. Friends praising friends.
    Ask prof for a letter of req & don’t wave the right to view it…….see how valuable it isn’t.

  • I believe that the next decade will be largely about reputation and the systems that support it. As you suggest there isn’t much that is really worthwhile out there yet. This new venture will open out the field – we’ll see where things go from there.

  • amieeyang

    Not merely are they soothing on the skin, Wholesale Plus Size Bridal Gownsdresses in such fabrics can quickly be jazzed up or played down.Blue wedding dress A strapless floral print dress is perfect for the daytime, and it is possible to straightforward put on a stylish jacket over it to turn it into the perfect evening put on. The same goes for off-shoulder and spaghetti style dresses.Short Bridal Dresses It is possible to team them up with trendy shoes as well as a handbag to develop a chic and classy look. However,Informal Wedding Dresses Wholesale if it’s fall or winter parties which you are thinking of attending, the most effective bet is usually to go with dresses in silk, satin, fine-gauge knits, or rayon. An empire-waist dCheap Plus Size Bridal Dresses Shopress when Plus Size Bridal Gowns Factoryput collectively with a silk of velvet shoulder Beach Bridal Gowns Factorywrap can create really a striking impact.

  • If you want to make beautiful hair style,
    GHD straightener absolutely is the best hair maker for
    you, it does little harm to the hair with safe and strong materials, so many
    people are happy to choose GHD. You may always wonder how to form a hairstyle
    as beautiful as superstar and also seem smooth smooth, that is due to they
    choose GHD straighteners to shape hair to reach the perfect pattern of men and
    women like. ghd IV salon styler can be thought of the very most
    popular and hottest hair styler, the first choice of hair salons has been their
    constant habit over the years. So hot hair straightners finding, come to GHD
    store online you’ll find a good hair day here, professional service and cheap
    price both raise patron’s interest in our GHD store.wilson tennis rackets

  • Winnibridal is a professional wedding gowns B2C website.It supplies white wedding gowns,Groom wears,Cheap wedding dress,Bridal ware,Flower girl dresses,Wedding gowns dresses,Wedding suppliers

  • Anonymous

    Gucci is one of the leading names in luxury and style. With its outstanding quality, fine Italian craftsmanship and exceptional beauty, Gucci outlet offers you only the best Gucci bags.We lead you to a genuine pool of bags  the collections in wide range Gucci outlet online, discount Gucci, Gucci men bags, Gucci tote bags,  Gucci on sale,and so are dedicated to bring you the top grade replicas gucci handbags. Cheap Gucci briefcase.We know that the quality of the product directly results in the impression given to people. Everyone hope to get noticed by their taste and elegant quality,Gucci Wallet, so our goal is to meet your demands. we believe that only focusing on quality can make us exist as long as possible. In addition to the good quality of Gucci bag,Gucci 85th Anniversary, we offer competitive pricing, our goal has been to earn the trust and satisfaction of the customer. We are determined to combine honest and helpful dealings with outstanding service before, during, and after the sale. Just go through on our  for all Gucci collections,Gucci Backpack, and you could get all you want!

  • Tessa Ye